Five Keys

Five Keys


Singles: 78 rpm

ALADDIN (3085 “With a Broken Heart”) $200-$250 / 1951

ALADDIN (3099 “The Glory of Love”) $75-$125 / 1951

ALADDIN (3113 “It’s Christmas Time”) $75-$125 / 1951

ALADDIN (3118 “Yes Sir, That’s My Baby”) $75-$125 / 1952

ALADDIN (3127 “Red Sails in the Sunset”) $100-$150 / 1952

ALADDIN (3131 “Mistakes”) $75-$125 / 1952

ALADDIN (3136 “I Hadn’t Anyone ‘Til You”) $75-$125 / 1952

ALADDIN (3158 “I Cried for You”) $75-$125 / 1952

ALADDIN (3167 “Can’t Keep from Crying”) $75-$125 / 1953

ALADDIN (3175 “There Ought to Be a Law”) $75-$125 / 1953

ALADDIN (3190 “These Foolish Things”) $75-$125 / 1953

ALADDIN (3204 “Teardrops in Your Eyes”) $75-$25 / 1953

ALADDIN (3214 “My Saddest Hour”) $200-$250 / 1953

ALADDIN (3228 “Some Day, Sweetheart”) $100-$150 / 1954

ALADDIN (3245 “Deep in My Heart”) $75-$125 / 1954

ALADDIN (3263 “My Love”) $75-$125 / 1955

ALADDIN (3312 “Story of Love”) $40-$60 / 1956

CAPITOL $50-$75 / 1954-1957

GROOVE (0031 “I’ll Follow You”) $1000-$2000 / 1954


Singles: 7–inch

ALADDIN (3099 “The Glory of Love”) $500-$750 / 1951

ALADDIN (3113 “It’s Christmas Time”) $1000-$1500 / 1951

ALADDIN (3118 “Yes Sir, That’s My Baby”/ “Old MacDonald”) $6000-$8000 / 1952
(B-side plays “Teardrops in My Eyes”)

ALADDIN (3118 “Yes Sir, That’s My Baby”/ “Old MacDonald”) $1500-$2000 / 1952
(B-side plays “Old MacDonald”)

ALADDIN (3127 “Red Sails in the Sunset”) $1500-$2500 / 1952

ALADDIN (3131 “Mistakes”) $750-$1000 / 1952

ALADDIN (3136 “I Hadn’t Anyone ‘Til You”) $1000-$1500 / 1952

ALADDIN (3158 “I Cried for You”) $750-$1000 / 1952

ALADDIN (3167 “Can’t Keep from Crying”) $750-$1000 / 1953

ALADDIN (3175 “There Ought to Be a Law”) $1500-$2000 / 1953

ALADDIN (3190 “These Foolish Things”) $2000-$3000 / 1953

ALADDIN (3204 “Teardrops in Your Eyes”) $500-$750 / 1953

ALADDIN (3214 “My Saddest Hour”) $600-$800 / 1953
(Flat blue label)

ALADDIN (3214 “My Saddest Hour”) $500-$750 / 1953
(Glossy blue label)

ALADDIN (3228 “Some Day, Sweetheart”) $500-$750 / 1954

ALADDIN (3245 “Deep in My Heart”) $500-$750 / 1954

ALADDIN (3263 “My Love”) $150-$250 / 1954

ALADDIN (3312 “Story of Love”) $300-$400 / 1956

BIM BAM BOOM (116 “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”) $4-$6 / 1973
(Black vinyl)

BIM BAM BOOM (116 “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”) $5-$8 / 1973
(Red vinyl)

CAPITOL (828 “Just for a Thrill”) $50-$75 / 1957
(Promo issue only)

CAPITOL (2945 “Ling Ting Tong”) $40-$50 / 1954

CAPITOL (3032 “Close Your Eyes”) $30-$40 / 1955

CAPITOL (3127 “The Verdict”) $30-$40 / 1955

CAPITOL (3185 “I Wish I’d Never Learned to Read”) $30-$40 / 1955

CAPITOL (3267 “‘Cause You’re My Lover”) $30-$40 / 1955

CAPITOL (3318 “What Goes On”) $30-$40 / 1956

CAPITOL (3392 “I Dreamt I Dwelt in Heaven”) $30-$40 / 1956
(Standard 45 rpm hole)

CAPITOL (3392 “I Dreamt I Dwelt in Heaven”) $50-$75 / 1956
(LP-size, 1/4-inch hole. Purple label)

CAPITOL (3392 “I Dreamt I Dwelt in Heaven”) $50-$75 / 1956
(LP-size, 1/4-inch hole. White label. Promo issue only)

CAPITOL (3455 “Peace & Love”) $30-$40 / 1956

CAPITOL (3502 “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”) $30-$40 / 1956

CAPITOL (3597 “Wisdom of a Fool”) $20-$30 / 1956

CAPITOL (3660 “Let There Be You”) $20-$30 / 1957

CAPITOL (3710 “Four Walls”) $20-$30 / 1957

CAPITOL (3738 “This I Promise You”) $20-$30 / 1957

CAPITOL (3786 “Face of an Angel”) $20-$30 / 1957

CAPITOL (3830 “Do Anything”) $20-$30 / 1957

CAPITOL (3861 “From Me to You”) $15-$25 / 1958

CAPITOL (3948 “With All My Heart”) $15-$25 / 1958

CAPITOL (4009 “Handy Andy”) $20-$30 / 1958

CAPITOL (4092 “Our Great Love”) $15-$25 / 1958

CAPITOL (6000 series) $8-$12 / 1964

CLASSIC ARTISTS (112 “Miracle Moment of Love”) $5-$8  / 1989
(Black vinyl. 1000 made)

CLASSIC ARTISTS (112 “Miracle Moment of Love”) $8-$10 / 1989
(Red vinyl. 1000 made)

CLASSIC ARTISTS (115 “I Want You for Christmas”) $5-$8  / 1989
(Black or brown vinyl. 1000 made)

CLASSIC ARTISTS (115 “I Want You for Christmas”) $8-$10  / 1989
(Red vinyl. 1000 made)

GUSTO $3-$5

IMPERIAL (016 “The Glory of Love”) $5-$10 / 1962

INFERNO (4500 “No Matter”) $5-$10 / 1967

KEY (62 “Wisdom of a Fool”) $5-$10

KEY (63 “The Verdict”) $5-$10

KING (5251 “I Took Your Love for a Toy”) $30-$40 / 1959

KING (5273 “Dream On”) $15-$20 / 1959

KING (5302 “How Can I Forget You”) $15-$20 / 1959

KING (5330 “Rosetta”) $10-$15 / 1960

KING (5358 “I Didn’t Know”) $10-$15 / 1960

KING (5398 “Valley of Love”) $10-$15 / 1960

KING (5446 “You Broke the Only Heart”) $10-$15 / 1961

KING (5496 “Stop Your Crying”) $15-$25 / 1961

KING (5877 “I Can’t Escape from You”) $5-$10 / 1964

LANDMARK (101 “Goddess of Love”) $10-$20 / 1973
(Black vinyl)

LANDMARK (101 “Goddess of Love”) $100-$200 / 1973
(Multi-colored vinyl. 25 made, of which no two are exactly alike. Colors and combinations of patterns and streaks vary with each record, and sometimes from side to side)

OWL (321 “A Dreamer”) $4-$6 / 1973

POPULAR REQUEST $3-$5

SEG-WAY (1008 “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”) $10-$20 / 1962

U.A. (0150 “Glory of Love”) $5-$10 / 1960s


Picture Sleeves

CAPITOL (3502 “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”) 400-500 / 1956
(Die-cut sleeve with photo insert. Promo issue only)


EPs: 7–inch

CAPITOL (572 “The Five Keys”) $150-$250 / 1955

CAPITOL (1-828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $300-$400 / 1957
(In cover photo, group member on left is holding his right hand in in a phallic-like position)

CAPITOL (1-828 “The Five Keys on  Stage”) $100-$200 / 1957
(Reworked cover, with offending hand removed from picture)

CAPITOL (2-828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $300-$400 / 1957
(In cover photo, group member on left is holding his right hand in in a phallic-like position)
CAPITOL (2-828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $100-$200 / 1957
(Reworked cover, with offending hand removed from picture)

CRYSTAL (101 “Five Keys”) $15-$25 / 1970s
(Blue vinyl)


LPs: 10/12–inch

ALADDIN (806 “Best of the 5 Keys”) $2000-$4000 / 1956
(Maroon label)

CAPITOL (828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $400-$600 / 1957
(In cover photo, group member on left is holding his right hand in a phallic-like position)

CAPITOL (828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $600-$800 / 1957
(Black label, reads “Sample Album for Radio-TV Program Use.” Cover has white sticker reading “For Promotional Use Only – Not for Sale.” In cover photo, group member on left is holding his right hand in a phallic-like position)

CAPITOL (828 “The Five Keys on Stage”) $100-$200 / 1957
(Reworked cover, with offending hand removed from the picture)

CAPITOL (1769 “The Fantastic Five Keys”) $100-$200 / 1962
(With “T” prefix)

CAPITOL (1769 “The Fantastic Five Keys”) $8-$12 / 1977
(With “M” prefix)

GREAT GROUP CLASSICS $8-$12 / 1970s

HARLEM HITPARADE $10-$15 / 1972

KING (688 “The Five Keys”) $300-$400 / 1960

KING (692 “Rhythm & Blues Hits – Past and Present”) $250-$350 / 1960

KING (5013 “14 Hits”) $8-$12 / 1978

SCORE (4003 “On the Town”) $500-$750 / 1957


The love of vinyl motivates us to keep adding artists. Help keep us going! Thank you